A school spending money on ads, flyers and a social media manager usually cannot answer one question: which of those produced the twelve students who enrolled last month.
Without that, the budget gets set by whichever channel felt busiest.
Cost per enrolment, not cost per lead
Leads are easy to buy and easy to be misled by. A channel producing forty cheap enquiries that convert at 3% is worse than one producing six that convert at 50%, and a cost-per-lead report will rank them the other way around.
Divide what you spent on a channel by the number of students who actually enrolled from it. That is the only figure worth comparing across channels.
You need one field, filled every time
How did you hear about us, on the student record, from a fixed short list. That is the whole attribution system, and it is enough at your scale.
It has to be filled at enrolment, by whoever enrols them, every time. A field that is optional is a field that is empty for the students you most want to understand.
Free text ruins it: forty spellings of "Facebook" cannot be counted. Six options and "other" can.
Expect word of mouth to win, and act on it
Almost every school that starts measuring finds referrals are the largest and cheapest source, by a distance. The usual mistake is to conclude nothing needs doing, because it is free.
It is not free - it is unmanaged. It responds to being asked at the right moment, which is the single highest-return marketing activity available to a small school. See the cheapest enrolment is one you are not asking for.
Judge a channel on a term, not a week
Enrolment cycles are seasonal and lumpy. A channel that produced nothing in a quiet fortnight has told you almost nothing.
Give a channel a term, a fixed budget and a number to beat, decided in advance. Then keep it or stop it. Channels that are neither working nor stopped are how a marketing budget quietly doubles.
A channel with no target is a channel you will keep paying for out of politeness.
And check the cheapest thing first
Before spending more on reaching new families, look at the enquiries you already have that nobody followed up. That backlog converts better than anything you can buy, and it costs nothing but the phone call.